Quick Summary: The Oster CKSTRS23 Quart Self-Basting Roaster is clearly the best roaster oven for me, largely because at 22 quarts, it will accommodate a 26-pound turkey. If I need it, this roaster has the capability to accommodate the largest bird. Oster roaster ovens are easy to use stupid resistant results and help you create holiday and special occasion dishes that are moist, tender, and delicious. By doubling your regular stove space to prepare more efficient meals, you save time and energy.
The best roaster oven should have a good size capacity, removable elements, even heat distribution, and be easy to clean as well as easy to use. Some roaster ovens also feature a self-basting lid which adds extra flavor to the food.
Other models are more versatile and will allow you to not only roast a whole turkey, but also cook food in other ways such as baking, steaming, slow cooking, or even warming up pre-prepared appetizers and other foods.
Many models are stainless-steel, and others have non-slip grips, heat-safe handles, and other features. Some roaster ovens have a very thin shell or space between the outside of the oven and your pan.
The thinner the shell, the more space you’ll get inside the oven. You want an oven that will take up as little countertop space as possible while giving you the most amount of cooking space inside. But how do you decide which roaster oven is the very best model for you and your needs?
We’ve done all of the painstaking research into the best roasting ovens on the market today, to save you time and effort. Take a look at our top picks for roaster ovens.
Quick Navigation
- Top 10 Roaster Ovens Comparison
- Reviews Of Top 10 Roaster Ovens
- Key Features of a Good Roaster Oven
- Our Recommendations
Top 10 Roaster Ovens Comparison
 | 1. Oster CKSTRS23-SB 22 Quart Roaster Oven (Best Overall)If you're tired of haplessly basting your chicken while it's roasting, then this self-basting Oster oven is for you. This roaster oven can handle 26-pound turkeys and features a lid that keeps moisture inside to remove the manual basting process. | Read Our Review |
 | 2. Nesco Professional Stainless Steel Roaster Oven (Best Budget)Spice up your kitchen with this 18-quart capacity portable roaster oven. It boasts a stunning red finish and effectively performs all oven functions except broiling. The adjustable full-range temperature control allows you to heat it to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. | Read Our Review |
 | 3. Proctor Silex 32191 Roaster Oven, Stainless SteelPrepare your turkey for the holidays with ease thanks to the 24-lb capacity of this stunning stainless steel Proctor Silex roaster oven. Roast and bake moist and tender meats without worrying about taking up space in your main oven. | Read Our Review |
 | 4. Rival RO180-18 Quart Roaster OvenAre you tired of your food coming out of your oven dry and unappetizing? The Rival Roaster Oven features an even heat distribution that guarantees moist and tender results. This cooker is extremely versatile and a great addition to your kitchen. | Read Our Review |
 | 5. Hamilton Beach 28 Lb Turkey Roaster OvenBring the party anywhere with Hamilton Beach's portable series. This roaster oven is perfect for cooking and serving on the go. It features a simple control knob, cool-touch side handles and easy to clean design to avoid any complications. | Read Our Review |
 | 6. Oster Smoker Roaster Oven, 16-Quart, Red SmokeThe Oster Smoker roaster oven is one of the best versatile additions you can put in your kitchen. This electric oven lets you smoke, roast and slow cook any meal. | Read Our Review |
 | 7. Oster Roaster Oven with Buffet Server, 18 QuartSave time and energy with this highly efficient Oster roaster oven. Roast and serve with ease thanks to this electric buffet server that features three removable enamel-coated steel pans and lids that keeps your dishes warm. | Read Our Review |
 | 8. Hamilton Beach Quart Roaster Oven (Stainless Steel)The most convenient portable kitchen tool is here to save the day. This Hamilton Beach turkey roaster oven has a 28-lb capacity and allows you to roast, bake, cook and serve without complications. | Read Our Review |
 | 9. 20 Quart Electric Roaster OvenWith this 20-quart stainless steel creation, you never have to worry about your food getting cold. This electric roaster oven features a keep warm setting that allows you to cook ahead of serving time without the need for reheating. | Read Our Review |
 | 10. Sunvivi 18 Quart Electric Roaster OvenThe ultimate portable device for your holiday needs. This 18-quart electric roaster oven features cool-touch handles that keep you safe from burns and an easy to clean design that guarantees a stress-free use. | Read Our Review |
Reviews Of Top 10 Roaster Ovens
Everything will affect the quality of your food. The top roaster ovens will increase the functionality of your kitchen, conserve energy, are versatile, produce delectable meals, and make your life easier.
1. Oster CKSTRS23-SB 22 Quart Roaster Oven
This roasting pan will cook a 26-pound turkey or roast.The self-basting lid does all the work for you, eliminating the need to manually baste while evenly circulating the heat and helping to seal in food’s natural juices.
Simmer gravy in the removable porcelain enamel lining and keep your stovetop burners free, or use it as an attractive serving dish.
The variable temperature control dial allows you to set cooking temperatures from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit.
In addition to roasting, you can bake cookies, pies, cakes, and muffins by simply placing your baking pan on the included rack. Just set the appropriate temperature and wait. This roaster oven cooks your food 30% faster than your convection oven and uses 36% less energy.
Pros:
- Self-basting
- Wide temperature range for roasting and slow cooking
- Bakes
- Removable rack
- Easy clean-up
Cons:
- Enameled stainless steel cooking surface
- Metal casing gets quite hot
- Expensive
2. Nesco 4818-25PR Professional Stainless Steel Roaster Oven
This 18-quart roaster roasts up to a 22-pound turkey or roast and bakes as well, accommodating a 9X9 square pan, two 9X5 loaf pans, 6 or 12 cup bundt pan, or a 9-inch pie pan.
It also has a non-porous surface that resists scratches.
Pros:
- Temperature control ranges from 200 to 450 degrees
- Attractive stainless steel base and lid
- Indicator light turns off when desired heat is reached
- Stay cool handles
- 18 – Quarts, large enough for cooking a 22-pound turkey
- Self-basting lid
- Porcelain enamel coated steel removable inner lining
- Roasts, steams, bakes and slow cooks
- Designed for commercial-level or volume cooking
Cons:
- Surface can tend to be hot
- Stainless steel body is thin
- Inner lining cooking well advertised is actually Teflon coated
- Needs to be ‘cured’ for an hour before using
3. Proctor Silex 32191 Roaster Oven, Stainless Steel
This versatile roaster oven is ultra-portable and takes up less room on your counter. If you’re a camper or enjoy potluck dinners, this oven is ideal for its ease of use and portability.
Although it holds only 6.5 quarts, it does the job of the larger roasters but on a smaller scale and will roast whole chickens and small roasts to perfection.
Because of its versatility, I wish I had purchased one of these instead of my crockpot. It’s like crockpot on steroids.
Pros:
- Ultra-portable
- Uses less counter space
- Enameled cooking well for easy cleanup
- Wide temperature range
- Can be used as a server
- Enamel coated cooking vessel
- Bakes
- Can be used as a slow cooker
- White outer body
Cons:
- Inner lining can scorch
- No indicator light to tell you it’s on
- Not self-basting
- Its 6.5 quart cooking well makes it smaller than its competitors
4. Rival RO180-18 Quart Roaster Oven
This 18-quart roaster oven can accommodate a large roast turkey up to 18 pounds and has an adjustable temperature gauge from 150 to 450 degrees.
With a temperature this low, it can also be used as a slow cooker, eliminating the need for a crock pot. And don’t forget its use of turkey fryer which is a complete bonus.
Pros:
- Large enough to accommodate a 9X13 baking pan
- Portable
- Removable steel roasting rack
- Removable roasting pan
- Choice of white or black outer body
- Inexpensive
Cons:
- Outer body can tend to be too hot/not well insulated
- Not very non-stick cooking well
- Not self-basting
5. Hamilton Beach 28 Lb Turkey Roaster Oven
This kitchen appliance will double your oven space and can roast up to a 28-pound turkey. It will also bake just about anything your conventional oven can bake, including pies.
Its temperature range is great for warming food as well as slow cooking. And it comes in two colors making it an attractive addition to your countertop.
Pros:
- 22-Quart capacity
- Choice of two attractive colors: red and stainless steel
- Self-basting lid
- Can cook up to a 28-pound turkey or roast
- Bakes
- Slow cooks
- Buffet server
- Lift out rack for large roasts
- Easy clean up enameled cooking well
- Can fit one 9X13 pan or two 9X5 loaf pans
- Sides remain cool while cooking
- Inexpensive
Cons:
- Reports of inconsistent heating/cooking time
- Enamel can chip off cooking well
6. Oster Smoker Roaster Oven
You’ll love the versatility of this Oster Smoker roaster oven: you can use it to smoke, roast, bake, or slow cook your food.
This beautifully designed red oven is a 16-quart roaster that can roast up to a 20-pound turkey. It weighs 16.3 pounds and has a sturdy inner enamel pan that lifts out easily with two inner handles.
Save energy and space in your main oven, use it when it’s too hot to turn on the oven, or when you want to cook smaller quantities of food.
Adjustable temperature control – Adjust the heat from 150 to 450 degrees F.
Easy to clean – The enamel-coated steel roasting pan as well as the rack are both removable for easy cleaning without any mess.
Stylish enough to serve from – You could easily set this gorgeous roaster oven in the center of your table. Serve guests quickly and easily.
Pros:
- This model has removable pockets that you can use to hold wood chips for outdoor smoking.
- Hickory, cherry, apple, or mesquite-flavored meats can be made indoors or out.
Cons:
- The capacity of this oven is not as much as other models which can roast a turkey up to 22 pounds.
7. Oster Roaster Oven with Buffet Server
You’ll love the buffet server that comes with this roaster oven for easy entertaining! An excellent appliance for extra cooking room for the holidays, too.
This flexible, 18-quart roaster oven can roast turkey and other meat, as well as act as a mini buffet for 3 different types of food.
Keep your dishes warm while serving; then simply lift the removable enamel on steel pans from the base for easy cleanup.
The lid fits snugly to keep in heat and moisture to ensure roasting with maximum flavor. You can adjust the temperature range from 150 to 450 degrees F with a simple twist of a dial.
3 removable smaller pans with lids – These smaller pans are perfect for keeping smaller quantities of food warm, buffet-style, for guests to serve themselves at their leisure.
Removable steel rack – The removable rack ensures that your food is raised above the cooking liquid and will be perfectly cooked on the bottom as well as on the top.
Energy-saver – This roaster oven uses 36% less energy than a conventional oven.
Pros:
- Highly versatile. You can make everything from lasagnas to cakes, muffins, stews, and roasted meat
Cons:
- This model has an 18-quart capacity, which is less than other models
8. Hamilton Beach 28 lb 22-Quart Roaster Oven
You’ll love the large capacity of this classic roaster oven, even compared to a traditional oven! This high-quality model can hold up to a 28-pound turkey, perfect for large family gatherings and holiday celebrations.
This is the perfect answer to extra oven space. The temperature can be adjusted from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, and the roasting tray is easily lifted out to carry large items to the table.
Make cakes, pies, bread, and casseroles: the oven fits one 9” by 13” baking pan, or two 9” by 5” loaf pans or one tube/Bundt pan.
Removable interior pan – The roasting pan made of enamel-on-steel is simple to lift out, making the transfer from oven to platter easy and hassle-free.
Simple to clean – As well as the removable pan, the removable roasting rack with handles and the lid can be taken out of the housing and washed in hot, soapy water.
Versatile – This stainless steel roaster oven can also bake and warm, as well as prepare soups, stews, and sides.
Pros:
- This 22-quart roaster oven has the highest capacity among the 10 best overall models
Cons:
- For using steam, no separate ovenproof containers are provided
9. 20 Quart Electric Roaster Oven
You’ll love the simple ‘keep warm’ feature of what we consider to be the best electric roaster. Just turn the button to ‘keep warm’, and heat preservation is guaranteed.
This stainless steel electric roaster oven has a 20 quart capacity and variable temperature control, as well as a steam hole feature in the self-basting lid.
The high dome cover allows for the height of a 22 pound (large) turkey, large chicken, and other roasts while keeping the heat firmly locked in.
You can bring it with you to BBQ parties and holiday gatherings. You can roast meats, heat soups, bake, poach, and steam. The ‘circle of heat’ heating elements ensure even heat distribution.
Cold touch handle – The lid of this electric oven has a cold touch handle, ensuring you don’t have to use oven gloves when opening the lid.
Self-basting lid – Keep moisture flowing over your roasts with the self-basting lid for maximum tenderness and flavor.
Removable components – The steel grill and pan are both easily removed for simple serving and cleanup.
Pros:
- Includes a ‘defrost’ feature
Cons:
- Before using for the first time, make sure to turn on the unit and let it heat while empty for a few minutes to burn off the ‘new’ smell
10. Sunvivi 18 Quart Electric Roaster Oven
You’ll love this stainless steel roaster oven with a self-basting lid no more having to lift the lid every so often to baste your food. Roasts will come out deliciously moist every time.
With 18 quarts of capacity, this is one of the best electric models. It lets you bake, boil, roast, or warm food anywhere.
The settings include a ‘defrost’ feature, and the removable grill pan make it easy to wash clean with warm soapy water. The cold touch handle ensures you won’t burn yourself as you lift the lid.
Portable – This 18-quart roaster oven is easy to take with you on holiday or to celebrations and BBQs.
Preserves heat – The ‘keep warm’ button keeps the heat locked inside while you wait for guests to sit down to eat.
Simple temperature control – The multiple temperature settings allow you to raise or lower the temperature as needed by turning the dial to precisely the heat setting that you require.
Pros:
- Removable steel grill and pan which makes it easy to transfer food from the roaster to the table.
Cons:
- The sides of this 18 quart roaster oven get very hot while in use
Key Features of a Good Roaster Oven
Energy Conservation
Regardless of their size, all roaster ovens use less energy compared to cooking with a microwave, crock pot, convection oven, electric oven, or gas oven.
And because you don’t have to periodically open the lid to manually baste your bird or roast, there is very little heat loss. They won’t heat up your kitchen in the warmer weather as regular ovens do.
If you are green minded, or simply intent on cutting utility costs, a roaster oven is a conservationists’ dream. You can even bake in most of them.
Versatility
You should take the size of your kitchen and counter-top space into consideration when purchasing a roaster oven.
The larger ovens obviously assume more counter-space than the smaller ones, but there are enough products to choose from to accommodate those needs.
Do you want something attractive that will remain on the counter? Or will your oven be something used only for cooking during holidays and special occasions, then tucked in a closet or cabinet the remainder of the year?
Regardless of an oven’s size, they are portable enough to be packed away when not in use or even carried to friend’s homes for sharing potluck dinners.
Their versatility doesn’t stop there. They can be used as a crockpot for slow cooking. You can bake in them. And they can be used for serving from counter-top to table.
Roaster Ovens Design
In terms of versatility and convenience, the best roaster ovens are designed for ease of use, quick clean-ups, and safety. Regardless of the material of which they’re made, they are insulated to minimize external heat emission and burns.
Their chords are short to eliminate entanglements with other appliances on your counter, and their inner lining or cooking well can be removed for an easy and thorough cleaning.
The heating coils contained in the sides and bottom of the roasters are designed to produce even and consistent heat throughout the cooking process and a control dial allows you to select the appropriate temperature.
Our Recommendation for the Best Roaster Oven
The Oster CKSTRS23 –SB 22 Quart Self-Basting Roaster oven lid that adds extra space to your roaster and seals in the juices, making your turkey or roast so moist and tender it falls off the bone right into your mouth.
For the size, aesthetics, versatility, durability, and desired results, the Oster CKSTRS23 –SB 22 Quart Oven is my choice. Although the Oster Quart Self-Basting Roaster Oven can accommodate a large 26-pound turkey, it is more expensive.
The Hamilton Beach 28 Lb Turkey Roaster Oven is clearly the best roaster oven for me, largely because at 22 quarts, it will accommodate a 28-pound turkey. If I need it, this roaster has the capability to accommodate the largest bird.
While all the roaster ovens can bake, it can hold as many baked goods as the more expensive Oster CKSTRS23-SB 22 Quart Roaster Oven.
I also preferred the attractive red color option of the Hamilton Beach over the dull black, and white outer bodies of the other roasters.
I chose the red roaster to brighten my kitchen counter-top. It just feels more festive and the darker color is more resistant to showing stains.
With the exception of the Nesco 4818 23PR whose lowest temperature is 200 degrees, the Hamilton Beach Turkey Roaster Oven, as well as its other competitors, allow for slow cooking and warming at 150 degrees.
Related reading
